Making Sustainability Profitable

RSJ Technical Consulting

What is Korea 'RoHS'?

Act No. 6319 - Resource Recycling

On April 2, 2007, the Act for Resource Recycling of Electrical and Electronic Equipment and Vehicles was adopted into law by the National Assembly of Korea. Many thanks to Jun-sik Yun and In-sung Park of Eco-Frontier (www.ecofrontier.co.kr)for their very readable translation, which is provided above.

Electrical and electronic equipment is defined as equipment or devices operated by electric currents or electromagnetic fields. The definition of vehicles is adopted from Article 2(1) of the Automobile Management Act.

Korea's equivalent of the RoHS, WEE and ELV directives adopts a characteristically Eastern approach by including "design for the environment" in its requirements. Implementation is geared toward continuous improvement in product design and recycling technology as they become technically possible and economically feasible. The Eastern value of cooperation above individualism results in goal-oriented regulation that reflects strong cooperation between government and producers.

The Act contains five major requirements for producers and importers:

  Restrictions on the use of hazardous substances, "such as heavy metals and flame retardants." Restrictions will apply to electrical/ electronic equipment and vehicles, but not to exports or research & development. Exceptions will be granted when there are no substitutes or the elimination of hazardous substances is extremely difficult.
  Improvement of materials and structure in products so that they are easy to recycle. Examples include using fewer and more easily recyclable materials, designing products so they are easier to dismantle, and making material composition information available to recyclers.
  Separate collection of waste products at no cost to the person disposing of them. Producers/importers of electrical/electronic equipment must designate a collection depot and inform the sellers of their products. Producers/importers of vehicles must contract with vehicle recyclers for processing ELV.
  Recycling rate: Manufacturers/importers of electrical/electronic equipment receive a  Mandatory Recycling Rate that is proportionate to their market share. To fulfill this rate they can collect and recycle their waste individually or join a Recycling Mutual Aid Association.
  Producers/importers of vehicles receive an Annual Recycling Rate which can be fulfilled by joining a Vehicle Recycling Association. Vehicle recyclers are paid the difference between the cost of recycling & disposing of ELV exceeds the value that can be recovered from recycling ELV (known as exceeding costs).
  Recycling Information Network is presumably an online database that producers/importers of electrical/electronic equipment and vehicles can use to provide recyclers with information about material composition and recycling methods for their products,   "to the extent confidential business information is not disclosed."

Sellers of electrical/electronic equipment must provide free take-back of customer's old products and packaging materials for new products. Sellers are responsible for transporting collected wastes to a collection depot/recycler (or they can reuse it themselves).

The Act provides only the framework for holding producers and importers responsible for their use of resources. The specifics are still to be decided by the Ministry of Environment (MoE), which will have an advisory Eco-Assurance Review Committee. Standards concerning hazardous substances and improvements in materials and structure will be decided jointly with the Ministry of Commerce, Industry and Energy.

The Act's effective date of January 1, 2008 will not mean much until the following decisions are issued by Presidential Decree,

  Restrictions on the use of hazardous substances: which hazardous substances to restrict and what the concentration limits will be; which cases will receive exemptions and how long the exemption will last; publication of Analysis Methods of Hazardous Substances
  Improvement of materials and structure: publication of Technical Guidance on the Improvement of Material and Structure for electrical/electronic equipment and Evaluation Methods of Recyclability for vehicles
  Recycling rates: what the Mandatory Recycling Rate will be for various types of electrical/electronic equipment and for individual producers/ importers; what the Annual Recycling Rate will be for vehicles and for individual producers/importers
  Recycling methods: publication of Recycling Methods and Standards by Product Categories for electrical/electronic equipment; Recycling Methods and Standards for vehicles; and the list of substances causing climate change

Korea's intent to follow the precedent set by European RoHS as well as to participate in establishing future international standards is reflected in Article 7, which instructs the MoE to take "appropriate measures for international cooperation," including mutual recognition between countries.

The Act provides for four different types of recyclers to process end-of-life vehicles:
  Vehicle recyclers dismantle vehicles and recycle its parts to the maximum extent possible; then transfer "residues" to shredders
  Vehicle shredding recyclers recover metallic materials from the residues and shred the rest of the dismantled vehicle; then transfer "shredder residues" to residue recycler
  Vehicle shredder residue recyclers recover metallic materials from shredder residues; then recycle and/or recover energy from the residues to the maximum extent possible
  Discarded gas recyclers segregate and store substances that cause climate change

Compliance and enforcement will be similar to that in the European Union. Producers/importers make self-declaration of compliance with the hazardous substance concentration limits. Self-declaration is also used for the annual recycling rate of vehicles.

The Act requires the following reports to be filed (with the MoE unless specified otherwise),
Electrical/electronic equipment:
  Recycling Requirement Implementation Plan -- submitted by the producer/importer/mutual aid association and approved before recycling begins
  Recycling Requirement Implementation Report -- submitted by the producer/importer/recycling mutual aid association
Vehicles:
  Performance Report on the Recycling of ELV and Energy Recovery
-- submitted quarterly by the producer/importer/vehicle recycling association
  Performance Report -- submitted quarterly by vehicle recyclers (to the Ministry of Construction & Transport)
  Performance Report -- submitted quarterly by vehicle shredding recyclers, vehicle shredder residue recyclers, and discarded gas recyclers
Transport:
  Manifest -- submitted by transportation carriers or recyclers when waste electrical/electronic equipment or end-of-life vehicles are transferred

The Act provides for posting required documents to an Operations Management Information System in lieu of paper record keeping. Although the information system will be established by the Moe, operation may be by a public corporation with relevant expertise. The scope of this system, and whether required reports may also be posted online, will not be clear until details are issued by Presidential Decree. However, it is interesting that Korea envisions moving documentation to an online database not unlike the one for IMDS.

Public officials may inspect business places, facilities, equipment and documents at any time to verify compliance with the Act. Notice is given seven days prior to the inspection, except when the destruction of evidence is a concern. The Ministry of Commerce, Industry & Energy will determine compliance with hazardous materials restrictions; the Ministry of Construction & Transportation will determine compliance with the annual vehicle recycling rate; and the MoE will determine all other compliance issues.

Korea views Act No. 6319 as the logical expansion of her Extended Producer Responsibility system (EPR), and many of the provisions are the same. Both programs are administered by the MoE who assigns each producer/importer a mandatory recycling amount that he must pay to recycle, either individually or as part of a mutual aid association. Failure to recycle the entire amount is met with recycling dues assessed with a 30% surcharge of actual cost. If the recycling dues are not paid within 30 days, an additional 5% penalty is imposed.

However, unlike EPR, Act No. 6319 does NOT specify exemptions for SMEs (small and medium enterprises). Although such exemptions could be written into a Presidential Decree, they are not part of the Act as it now stands.

This summary of Korea RoHS is designed to provide you with an accurate, easy-to-understand overview of the topic and does not constitute legal advice. The actual standard in the original language should be reviewed and used for all business, legal, and product compliance purposes.

Back to Tutorial Index

Copyright © 2007 -- All Rights Reserved
RSJ Technical Consulting
PO Box 867705, Plano, Texas 75086